09_The Silent Majority: Why the People Who Know the Most Say the Least

The day started with reports from last week's Gemba homework.

After The Gemba Gap lesson, Sage had challenged everyone to spend 30 minutes on the factory floor—not inspecting, but learning. Today, they'd share what they discovered.

One by one, team members shared what they'd learned by spending 30 minutes on the factory floor.

Mr. Dashley went first, looking uncomfortable.

"I talked to three operators near Station 4," he began slowly. "They told me they've known for 18 months how to reduce changeover time by 40%. They even tested it on night shifts. It works."

The room went silent.

"Eighteen months?" Rocky asked. "Why didn't they tell anyone?"

Dashley shifted in his seat. "They said they did. Twice. Their supervisor told them to 'stick to the standard work' and 'stop wasting time on ideas that are not backed with data, and are mere wishful thinking.'"

Mr. Deckson jumped in quickly. "Well, I discovered something similar. The maintenance crew designed a predictive checklist that could prevent 60% of our unplanned downtime. They've been using it informally for eight months."

"Eight months?!" Ms. Pristine exclaimed.

"They never brought it to engineering," Deckson admitted. "When I asked why, they said the last three suggestions they submitted... disappeared into email chains and never got responses."

The room felt heavy.

Sage, who had been listening quietly, finally spoke.

"This," he said calmly, "is what Amy Edmondson calls the absence of psychological safety. It's not that people don't have ideas. It's that they've learned it's not safe to share them."

Rocky nodded. He remembered. “We talked about this in The Feedback Gap—people avoid hard conversations when they fear the consequences.”

"Exactly," Sage confirmed. "But this goes deeper. Feedback flows between peers and up the chain. This? This is about frontline workers who've already learned that their voice doesn't matter."

He stood up and walked to the whiteboard.

"In her book The Fearless Organization, Edmondson found that in psychologically unsafe environments, people stay silent even when they know something is wrong. Why? Because past experience taught them that speaking up leads to punishment, dismissal, or being ignored."

Rocky looked troubled. "So we've been losing solutions for... how long?"

"Probably years," Sage said flatly.

He continued. "Google's Project Aristotle studied 180 teams and found that psychological safety was the number one predictor of high performance—more than talent, resources, or experience. Teams where people felt safe to speak up consistently outperformed teams with 'superstars' who stayed silent."

"Let me tell you two real stories," Sage said.

"First: the NASA Challenger disaster. Engineers at Morton Thiokol knew the O-rings would fail in cold temperatures. They tried to warn leadership the night before the launch. But the culture punished dissent, rewarded optimism, and dismissed concerns from 'lower-level' engineers. Seven astronauts died because the people who knew the most... didn’t speak."

The room was silent.

"Second: a study in healthcare found that 84% of nurses witnessed serious medical errors but didn't speak up. Why? Fear of retaliation, being labeled a troublemaker, or simply being ignored. Research shows that in hospitals with low psychological safety, patient mortality rates are significantly higher."

Mr. NoNo, who had been unusually quiet, finally spoke.

"I get it now. When I resisted changes... it wasn't just protecting old ways. I was protecting myself from being proven wrong. And that made everyone around me afraid to challenge me."

Sage smiled slightly. "Self-awareness is the first step."

Rocky asked, "So how do we fix this? How do we get people to speak up?"

Sage wrote four words on the whiteboard:

ASK → LISTEN → ACT → CREDIT

"It's that simple," Sage explained. "And that hard."

"Ask: Not 'Do you have any concerns?' That's too vague. Ask specific questions: 'What's the biggest waste you see?' 'If you could change one thing tomorrow, what would it be?' Invite and welcome new ideas in specific areas.

Listen: Don't interrupt. Don't defend. Don't explain why their idea won't work. Just... listen. Repeat what you heard to confirm understanding.

Act: Either implement the idea, or explain clearly why you can't—and what would need to change. The worst thing? Silence. When ideas disappear into a void, people stop sharing them.

Credit: Publicly acknowledge whose idea it was. Simon Sinek said in Leaders Eat Last that great leaders make people feel safe enough to take risks. Recognition reinforces that safety."

Mr. Deckson raised his hand hesitantly. "What if someone's idea genuinely won't work?"

"Then you honor the thinking," Sage replied. "Say: 'I love that you're thinking about this. Here's why it might not work in this context. But what if we tried this variation instead?' You're not rejecting the person. You're building on their contribution."

He paused, then added, "Liz Wiseman calls this being a Multiplier instead of a Diminisher. Multipliers are those who amplify people's intelligence. Diminishers shut it down. The tragedy? Most Diminishers don't even realize they're doing it. Remember The Ego Tax? Ego makes us dismiss ideas that don't come from us. That's textbook Diminisher behavior."

Rocky grinned. "So basically, we've been Diminishers?"

"Yes," Sage said bluntly. "But now you know. And awareness creates choice."

Rocky repeated : “Mmmm yes indeed …. Awareness creates choice!”. Rocky paused, then added thoughtfully, “You know, Sage... it's Ramadan now. My grandmother always quotes the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, who said that: 'Whoever does not give up false speech and acting upon it, Allah has no need of him giving up his food and drink.' She says fasting isn't just about controlling hunger—it's about controlling your tongue as well, and truly listening before you speak. She says it’s all about self-control."

Sage smiled warmly. "Your grandmother is wise, Rocky. Self-discipline and restraint—whether in Ramadan or in leadership—create space for others to be heard. When we control our impulse to interrupt, dismiss, or dominate... that's when real wisdom emerges."

As the meeting ended, and the team gathered their notes to leave, Rocky stayed behind.

"Sage... you said the people who know the most say the least. Imagine when the opposite happens, I mean, they start sharing everything they know?"

Sage's eyes lit up with that familiar spark.

"Then, Rocky, you'd discover something remarkable. The best innovations don't come from boardrooms or consultants. They come from the people closest to the work. And when you finally learn to listen..."

He paused, smiling mysteriously.

"...you'll realize you've been sitting on a goldmine of untapped genius this entire time."

Rocky's eyes widened.

But Sage just smiled and walked toward the door.

Next week, they'd discover what happens when operators are treated not just as hands.......but as the brilliant problem-solvers they've always been.

#MrSage #Leadership #BusinessExcellence #LeanThinking #TOC #ContinuousImprovement #Coaching #RespectforPeople #WorkplaceWisdom #PsychologicalSafety

Photo from Pexels by Mikhail Nilov

LET'S CONNECT

Newsletter

waleed.radwan@zedseven.org

+971-58822-4771

© 2024. All rights reserved.

Terms & conditions

JOIN the COMMUNITY

JOIN the MOVEMENT !