New Release ...... A new e-magazine ! ... Check our Shop for a free sneak peak.

15_The Identity Trap: Why Smart People Resist Smart Ideas

Resisting change because it affects my identity and my value, and how I'm preceived by others.

BUSINESS & LEAN MANAGEMENT

Waleed Radwan

6/1/20266 min read

The day started with silence — but not the usual kind.

No one was late. No one was on their phone. The team was still digesting last week's disruption — the supplier suspension, the scrambled plans, the wrong assumptions.

They weren’t expecting it to be that bad.

Sage had asked them each to rewrite one sentence: the one assumption inside their 90-day plan that the crisis had just proven wrong.

Most of them had done it. But one person hadn't.

Mr. NoNo sat with his notebook closed. Pen untouched.

Sage noticed. He didn't say anything. Not yet.

The updates went around the table. Dashley, Deckson, Pristine, Rocky. Each shared their revised assumption with varying degrees of comfort.

Then Sage turned to NoNo.

"NoNo?"

NoNo looked up. Took a breath.

"I couldn't write it," he said quietly. "Not because I didn't know what the wrong assumption was. I knew exactly which one."

He paused.

"But if I wrote it down... if I admitted that the process I'd protected for eleven years was built on a flawed assumption... then what was I doing?!"

The room went still.

"I wasn't protecting the process," NoNo said slowly. "I was protecting myself ! "

The Change Was Fine. Until It Was Personal.

Sage leaned forward. This was the moment he'd been waiting for — not with satisfaction, but with care. It wasn’t easy for NoNo to admit something like that ….and out loud.

"This," he said, "is the deepest resistance there is. And almost nobody talks about it."

He walked to the whiteboard — his favorite place in the world — and wrote two words: IDENTITY THREAT.

"Most leaders assume resistance to change is about stubbornness. Or laziness. Or politics. And sometimes it is. But the hardest resistance? It's none of those things. It's a person trying to protect who they believe they are."

Rocky glanced around the table. He thought about Mr. Remix — quietly rebranding ideas to protect his image. He thought about Deckson's 120-slide decks — a fortress built from expertise that nobody questioned. He thought about himself, honestly.

Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey, in their remarkable book Immunity to Change, describe what they call a hidden competing commitment. You want to change. You genuinely do. But underneath that desire sits a competing commitment — an invisible one — to protect an image, a status, or a belief about who you are. The two commitments cancel each other out. Like pressing the gas pedal and brake pedal at the same time. And the person looks resistant, when really they are terrified. Terrified of losing their image.

"It's not that people don't want to change. It's that they can't — until they feel safe enough to let go of who they thought they had to be."

The Supply Chain Had the Same Problem

Rocky looked at his phone briefly. The regional disruption …. Strait of Hormuz tension squeezing shipping lines, lead times doubling overnight ….. had forced every operations team in the region to rethink sourcing assumptions. But Rocky had noticed something interesting in the conversations around him this past week. Some leaders adapted fast. Others didn't move at all.

"It wasn't capability," Rocky said. "The ones who didn’t move — they knew what to do. Multi-source. Spot purchasing. Regional buffers. Qualify new material. Redesign. The knowledge was there."

"So what stopped them?" Pristine asked.

"Their identity," Rocky said, surprising himself a little. "They'd spent years building a reputation on just-in-time, low stock, single-source partnerships, reliability, innovation, center of excellence. Changing that felt like admitting the whole philosophy was wrong. It wasn't a logistics problem. It was a pride problem."

Sage pointed at him. "Exactly. And this is why identity threat is so dangerous in organizations. And it's hidden.”

What the Research Actually Shows

Carol Dweck's foundational work on Mindset goes deeper than most people apply it. A fixed mindset isn't just 'I can't learn new things.' At its core, a fixed mindset actually believes 'If I'm wrong, I'm worthless.' That equation …..between being wrong and being diminished….. is what makes identity-level resistance so paralyzing.

Chip and Dan Heath, in their book Switch, describe the emotional side of change as an Elephant — powerful, driven by feeling, not logic. You can give the Elephant the clearest rational argument in the world. But if the change threatens its sense of self….. it won't move. The Rider (logic) can't drag an Elephant that doesn't want to move.

As the old saying says: “You can pull a horse to the river, but you can’t force it to drink”

And Daniel Coyle, in The Culture Code, explains that feeling of belonging. It’s the sense of 'I am valued here as I am'….. and that’s the precondition for genuine change. When people feel their identity is under attack, they don't innovate. They defend. They go quiet. They become exactly the kind of Silent Majority we talked about a few weeks ago.

You Don't Need to Change the Person. Just Give Them a Bigger Identity.

Sage turned back to NoNo.

"Tell me something," Sage said quietly. "What do you actually know about these processes? After eleven years?"

NoNo looked up. "Everything. I know every failure mode. Every outlier. Every workaround that actually works, and the ones that don’t, but just look good on paper."

"Exactly," Sage said. "That knowledge doesn't disappear when the process changes. It becomes more valuable. Because you're the one who knows what to protect and what to let go. In fact, you're the best person to reshape this process, or even replace it."

He paused.

"We're not asking you to abandon what you know, NoNo. We're asking you to upgrade it. Revisiting your previous principles or changing your direction doesn’t mean you were wrong all these years. It means you were brave enough to adapt when you had to. In fact, you set a good example for your team. When a leader is brave enough to say, "I screwed up" or "I don't know," it signals to everyone else that it’s okay to take risks and ask for help. There's a difference between a man who defends a process, and a man who understands a system well enough to evolve it. The second one is far more valuable."

NoNo was quiet for a moment. Then he picked up his pen...and wrote:

"The greatest obstacle to change isn't ignorance. It's the illusion that your value only comes from what you already know."

Rocky's Grandma, As Usual, Said It Better

Rocky had been uncharacteristically quiet through most of this. He was thinking about his own hidden competing commitments — the ones he hadn't named yet.

Finally, he grinned.

"Grandma had a neighbour," he said. "A surgeon. Brilliant man. But he refused to learn laparoscopic surgery when it came out (you know… they call it menzar here in Arabic). He said open surgery was 'proven.' Took him four years to change. You know what he told Grandma afterwards?"

Sage raised an eyebrow. Not knowing what to expect.

"He said: 'I wasn't afraid of the new technique. I was afraid of being a beginner again.'"

The room absorbed that.

"Being a beginner," Sage said softly, "is the price of growth. And the leaders who are willing to pay it …. are the ones who last."

Inspired by Rocky’s comment….Sage wrote one final line on the whiteboard — right next to IDENTITY THREAT:

"The change was fine... until it was personal. Make it personal in a different way: Make growth part of who you are."

This Week's Challenge

Sage gave them one quiet assignment before they left.

"Think of one idea, one change, one piece of feedback you've been resisting. Ask yourself honestly: Is it actually a bad idea? Or does it threaten something you've built your identity around? Just sit with that question. You don't have to share the answer with anyone."

He looked around the room.

"Awareness creates choice," he said. "Rocky taught us that."

Rocky looked pleased.... then immediately suspicious. "Did you just compliment me?"

Sage smiled. "Yeah… but don't get used to it !"

As the team left the room, Rocky lingered, as usual.

"Sage... what if the person most trapped by their identity isn't in this room? What if it's someone higher up ..... someone who sets the culture for all of us?"

Sage stopped. Turned slowly. Still thinking.

"Then," Sage said quietly, "everything we've built here... could still unravel from the top."

Rocky frowned. "So what do we do?"

"Go home, Rocky, it’s late" Sage said, exhausted, "We talk about that next week”.

#MrSage #Leadership #BusinessExcellence #LeanThinking #TOC #ContinuousImprovement #Coaching #RespectforPeople #WorkplaceWisdom #ChangeManagement #ImmunityToChange #GrowthMindset

Photo from Pexels by Lamar Belina